New Delhi

The 14th Ministerial Conference of the World Trade Organization concluded in Yaoundé, Cameroon, without resolving one of its most debated issues — whether to continue the long-standing moratorium on customs duties for electronic commerce.

The four-day meeting, which began on March 26 and extended slightly beyond its scheduled close, ended with members unable to reach consensus on extending the duty-free regime for digital transactions such as downloads, streaming services, and other electronic transmissions.

First introduced in 1998, the moratorium has been renewed every two years, preventing countries from imposing tariffs on digital trade. However, this time negotiations stalled, primarily due to differences between major economies. While the United States pushed for a longer extension of up to five years, some countries, including Brazil, were hesitant, and others preferred a shorter two-year renewal. In the absence of agreement, the moratorium expired on March 31, potentially allowing nations to begin taxing digital imports.

Cameroon’s Trade Minister Luc Magloire Mbarga Atangana, who chaired the conference, acknowledged that while progress was made in several areas, time ran out before consensus could be reached on key unresolved matters, including the e-commerce framework and related moratoriums. Members agreed to continue discussions at the WTO headquarters in Geneva.

WTO Director-General Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala described the talks as constructive overall, pointing to advancements in areas such as fisheries subsidies and broader institutional reforms. She encouraged members to build on the draft proposals developed during the conference and work toward final agreements in future meetings.

The failure to extend the e-commerce moratorium marks a significant shift in global trade dynamics. Over the years, digital trade has expanded rapidly, with products once sold physically — like music, films, and books — now increasingly delivered online. The absence of a duty ban could allow governments to impose tariffs on such digital flows, potentially reshaping international trade practices.

Developing countries have long expressed concerns about the moratorium, arguing that it limits their ability to generate revenue and regulate a fast-growing digital economy. According to policy analysts, these nations could collectively lose billions of dollars annually due to forgone tariff income. For India, the estimated revenue loss is substantial, further strengthening its cautious stance on extending the measure indefinitely.

On the other hand, developed economies — supported by major technology firms — have advocated for a longer or permanent extension, citing the need to maintain an open and predictable digital trade environment.

The conference also saw the expiry of a related safeguard under the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS), which had previously protected countries from certain types of legal challenges. Its lapse could expose governments to disputes even when their domestic policies comply with WTO rules, particularly in sensitive areas such as public health and intellectual property regulation.

In addition, attempts to outline a clear roadmap for WTO reforms failed to gain consensus. Differences remain stark, with advanced economies pushing for faster decision-making processes and stricter disciplines, while developing countries continue to emphasise the importance of flexibility and consensus-based governance.

Despite these setbacks, ministers agreed to continue negotiations on multiple fronts, including fisheries subsidies, with the aim of presenting recommendations at the next ministerial conference.

READ MORE: Alfiya Pathan: The rising boxing Star from Nagpur, aspiring to be the Next Mary Ko

The outcome of MC14 highlights the growing divide within the global trading system, as countries struggle to balance the demands of a rapidly evolving digital economy with concerns over equity, sovereignty, and development priorities.